Several days prior to the Caucus, I correctly predicted the order in which the candidates would finish. So the fact that Santorum finished second should not have been a total surprise. But the fact that he came within 5 votes of winning is what changed everything. As a result, contrary to other predictions, Iowa wound up mattering more than many expected, including myself. Exactly how much more though is up to Rick Santorum.
In addition to ending Michele Bachmann’s campaign and giving movement conservatives a chance to divide their vote up among fewer candidates, Iowa shifted the focus on to a new contender…..Rick Santorum. But how much that matters depends upon Rick Santorum’s ability to capitalize on his new found fame. If he fails to come out of New Hampshire and South Carolina stronger than he was going in to them, then Iowa’s impact on the nomination will prove to have been minimal.
The one thing we do know is that the strong showing they provided Rick Santorum with was a political version of Groundhog Day……not the movie, but the actual holiday. Santorum, the former Senator from Pennsylvania, emerged from Iowa much like Punxsutawney Phil, the famed Pennsylvania groundhog who the nation watches as he emerges from his burrow. If he sees his shadow, it is said to indicate that winter weather will last longer than we may want. In Rick Santrorum’s case, his come from behind split decision in Iowa has cast a shadow on the Republican race which means that this nomination contest remains contested and will probably do so far longer than Republicans would like.
That situation was arrived at due to both Romney and Santorum.
In addition to running a strong campaign that was waged on principle, persistence, and elbow grease, Santorum never became the type of target that everyone who surged to the top found themselves to become. This helped him win voters over and keep them in his column. Had Santorum surged to the top like Newt Gingrich did weeks before voting began, he probably would have fallen victim to the same circumstances of those before him and now he will have a hard time proving that he can withstand such scrutiny.
As for Romney, although he technically won, to really win, he needed to stun Republicans with a strong first place finish with 30 or more percent of the vote. That would have changed the entire storyline coming out of Iowa. Instead of Rick Santorum being the main focus of the results, the real headline would have been that Mitt Romney finally exceeded the 25% ceiling of support that has become his greatest hurdle. And he would have done so in a state where he was hardly considered a favorite. Instead, not only did Romney almost lose to someone who was in the single digits a week before the caucuses, he actually won with 6 votes less than he received in 2008 when he came in second to Mike Huckabee. In 2008, Romney received 25.19% of the Iowa Caucus vote, just about the same as he did this time, but the raw total was 30,021 votes. In yesterday’ s caucus Romney won with 30, 015 votes.
Given that this was Romney’s second time around and he actually lost support, last night was really not a win for him. In the end, all that Iowa did for Romney was confirm that Republicans are still not excited about him and would like a better candidate.
So the race goes on and Romney is poised to become the first non-incumbent Republican presidential candidate to ‘technically’ win Iowa and New Hampshire. The problem is that between the reality of his poor showing in Iowa relative to Rick Santorum’s near defeat of him, and Romney’s win in new Hampshire being considered a given, those victories may not provide Mitt with the momentum he needs to assure himself of a win in South Carolina where Mitt may find himself either in his last stand or finally on course to winning the nomination.
Newt Gingrich, who currently leads in New Hampshire has been trying to build a firewall in South Carolina in the hope of finally establishing himself as the alternative to Romney. And Newt is looking for a fight with Mitt and is ready to provide him with some payback for all the negative ads that he believes Romney is behind.
Then there is Rick Perry.
Perry had time to sleep on his fifth place finish in Iowa and while he headed to bed with thoughts of ending his campaign dancing in his head, he woke up ready to fight and even Tweeted a battle cry that declared he is moving on to the Palmetto State.
And not to be Rick-rolled will be the other Rick, Rick Santorum, the new great conservative hope.
If Santorum can run strong enough in South Carolina to prevent Perry and Gingrich from getting out of the single digits or mid teens, at least one of the two will drop out and give Santorum the opportunity to bring their numbers in to his vote totals in the Florida primary which immediately follows South Carolina.
As for Ron Paul, given how far out of the mainstream his national security policies are and given his lack of legislative accomplishments in almost two decades in Congress, in order for him to have a major impact on future primary nomination contests, he needed a big win in Iowa. Add to that the buzz about polls which showed him actually in first place over the course of the weekend prior to the Caucus, and what you have is a candidate who failed to live up to expectations, and failed to meet a level of support that would have helped him overcome his perceived electability problems. Although Ron Paul ran well and his strong showing can not be denied, it was not strong enough to help him gain the type of traction that he needs. As a result, Ron Paul’s 22% percent in Iowa was probably his high watermark and from here on out, while he will remain a presence in the race, his impact on it will be about as significant as it was in his previous two runs for President.
Meanwhile the immediate effects of Iowa are apparent.
Since last night, interest in Santorum reached such heights that his website crashed and he collected $1 million in donations. That is a good indication of just how his strong showing in Iowa has indeed provided him with the opportunity to become the real viable alternative to Romney that many have been looking for.
Another good sign for Santorum is that several national evangelical leaders have decided to get together and determine which of the remaining candidates they can all get behind in an attempt to be certain that Romney is denied the Republican nomination. Given the circumstances, at the moment, Santorum would seem to be the most likely beneficiary of such an alliance.
At the moment I am not sure what will happen. I have a feeling that while Rick Santorum may now be considered the Great Conservative Hope, he will ultimately be like another great hope……Duane Bobick, the 197o’s boxing star who was jokingly refered to as the “Great White Hope”. Back in 1977, the biggest sporting event of the year became a much anticipated match between Bobick and future legend Ken Norton. Bobick had a a 38-0 record with 32 KO’s and when he entered the ring with Norton, millions were anticipating an epic fight between two extraordinary athletes. Less than 40 seconds in to the first round, Norton landed an overhand right to Bobick’s throat and after just one minute into the fight Bobick was counted out. A large part of me believes that this is Romney’s nomination and that Santorum will be the Duane Bobick of presidential politics.
Romney is still best poised to lock up the nomination soon after Florida. However; if the inevitability of a Romney candidacy becomes so obvious, and triggers the far right base of the G.O.P. to finally unite behind one candidate in an attempt to stop Romney, this could be either a long, drawn out battle or a quick turning of the tables. My biggest fear is that if conservatives really can not accept Mitt Romney and do not settle on who his one opponent should be, we could just find ourselves with the first brokered convention since 1976.
Filed under: Iowa, Mitt Romney, New Hampshire, Newt Gingrich, Rick Perry, Rick Santorum, Ron Paul, Strategy Tagged: | can santorum withstand the scrutiny, caucus results, Iowa, Iowa Groundgog Day, iowa Results, Mitt Romney, New Hampshire, Newt Gingrich, pauxutawney phil, Republican, rick rolled, Rick Santorum, Rick Santrorum Duane Bobick, Ron Paul, Santotum the great consewrvative hope, South Carolina, the 2012 presidential election, the election, the great whitye hope, the importance of south carolina, the Republican presidential candidates, The White House, What do the Iowa Caucus results, what does mmitt romney need to do now, what is next in the republican presidential race, where the candidates stand, White House 2012, will Rick Santorum win the nomination, Will Santorum be rick rolled, will the Iowa caucus matters, wordpress political blogs